Jump to main content
Circulant Hadamard

Local Character Comparison

Full overview · Local Character Comparison
Show the proof map

At each prime dividing u, comparing two neighboring character values gives a local unit with residue one.

The comparison we need

Fix a prime . We will compare evaluations at and at a primitive th root . Although reduces to above , we cannot simply reduce a quotient: its numerator and denominator might both vanish. The point of the proof is to cancel the necessary powers of first.

Lemma (Local comparison). Let have finite order coprime to . Let be localized at a maximal ideal containing ; this means allowing denominators outside that ideal. Suppose

where and is invertible in . Then

are units in and both have residue modulo .

Here a unit is an element with an inverse in the same ring. Both denominators are nonzero, since .

The cyclotomic fact used in the proof

We use the standard local cyclotomic facts in the paper's Lemma 2.1. In , every nonzero element is a power of times a unit. Its exponent is its valuation, written , with . After adjoining a primitive th root , valuations may be fractional but still add under multiplication. Put . The powers form an -basis. The ring is local with maximal ideal , so an element with nonzero residue is a unit. Moreover, if and , then every coefficient of is divisible by .

These facts come from the cyclotomic polynomial : after replacing by , it is Eisenstein at . Thus adjoining gives the stated basis, and is a unit times . Divisibility by can then be read coefficient by coefficient in that basis. This is the arithmetic input; the comparison itself follows by the descent below.

Base case: a cycle of length p

When , the integral valuations of and add to . At least one value is a unit; suppose it is . Since , and this ratio is a unit. Moreover,

The second ratio is its inverse, so it is also a unit of residue .

Shorten the cycle without changing either ratio

Suppose . At a primitive th root ,

Both valuations are nonnegative, so one is at least . Relabel the two factors if necessary so that . Divide its polynomial representative by the monic cyclotomic polynomial:

The cyclotomic fact makes all coefficients of divisible by . Now project to the shorter cycle by imposing ; write for this projection. Every term in becomes , so . Hence is coefficientwise divisible by . Define

They have coefficients in and satisfy . Cancelling is valid because the group ring is a free -module. At both and , projection changes neither evaluation. Division by cancels from the ratio, giving

The cycle exponent and scalar exponent have both fallen by one, while both ratios are unchanged. Induction reaches the base case and proves the lemma. The factor divided by may change from one step to the next.

Apply it to the norm solution

Let be the primes dividing , and put . Fix and a maximal ideal of above . The -component of has order , with .

For not containing , evaluate the other components of , leaving the -component variable. This produces two factors with product . Localize the coefficient ring generated by and the other roots at the ideal below ; their orders are coprime to , so the lemma applies. It gives

as a unit in . Here reduces to in characteristic . The inverse ratio has the same properties.

The matching exponent matters: it keeps the shortening process going until the unit argument at applies. We have therefore obtained a unit comparison of residue in every prime direction.

Source: the paper, Lemmas 2.1 and 3.1, Remark 3.2, and equation (3.4).

Back to The Δ-Theorem