Jump to main content
Circulant Hadamard

Kronecker's Theorem

Full overview · Kronecker's Theorem
Show the proof map

Integrality and unit magnitude for every conjugate force the alternating product to be a root of unity.

From integrality to finite order

Kronecker's theorem. If an algebraic integer has absolute value under every embedding of its number field into , then it is a root of unity.

A root of unity is a complex number for which for some positive integer . Its powers return to after finitely many rotations.

An algebraic integer is a root of a monic polynomial with integer coefficients. That integer condition is what prevents indefinitely many different powers on the unit circle.

Only finitely many polynomials can occur

Let be the degree of over . For every positive integer , the power is still an algebraic integer, has degree at most , and all its conjugates have magnitude .

Its monic minimal polynomial has integer coefficients. If its roots are , with , the coefficient places below the leading term is, up to sign, the sum of products of distinct roots. Each product has magnitude , so this coefficient has absolute value at most .

Thus the degree and every integer coefficient are bounded independently of . Only finitely many such polynomials exist, and each has finitely many roots. All powers therefore belong to a finite set.

Two equal powers finish the proof

There are positive integers with . Since , we can divide by to obtain

This proves the criterion. Both hypotheses were needed. For example, and its conjugate both lie on the unit circle, but their trace is , so they are not algebraic integers and are not roots of unity.

Apply the criterion

Node 4.2 established that every conjugate of has absolute value . Node 4.4 established that lies in , hence is an algebraic integer. Both hypotheses now hold, and Kronecker gives

The alternating product has finite order. This does not yet specify that the order is odd; the next step uses the local residue information retained from the integrality argument.

Source: the paper, Lemma 3.3(i) and Proposition 3.4.

Back to The Δ-Theorem