Jump to main content
Circulant Hadamard

The Product Is Integral

Full overview · The Product Is Integral
Show the proof map

Pairing subsets in each prime direction shows that the alternating product has no local denominator obstruction.

Lemma (Integrality). For odd and , the alternating product is an algebraic integer. At every prime above a divisor of , it is a unit with residue .

Check possible denominators one prime at a time

Let be the set of primes dividing , put , and let , the ring containing our evaluated values. Checking at a maximal ideal means allowing every denominator outside ; the resulting ring is written . For any fixed , pair a subset not containing with the subset obtained by adding . This rewrites the same alternating product as

At every maximal ideal of containing , Node 4.3 makes each ratio a unit with residue . Products and inverses preserve both properties. Thus is a unit of residue in . Repeat this pairing for each prime dividing .

At a maximal ideal containing none of those primes, is a unit. The identity

then makes every a unit there, with inverse . Consequently belongs to for every maximal ideal .

Recover a global integral element

Inside the fraction field of a domain, the intersection of all its localizations at maximal ideals is the original ring. Here is the denominator argument. If , the ideal

is proper. Choose a maximal ideal containing it. Writing with and would force , a contradiction. Thus .

Applying this to proves . The ring is generated by roots of unity, which are algebraic integers, so its elements are algebraic integers.

This supplies the integrality hypothesis needed for Kronecker's theorem. Keep the residue- information too: it will restrict the order of the resulting root of unity.

Source: the paper, Proposition 3.4, especially equation (3.5).

Back to The Δ-Theorem